To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we do not use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyses reviews to verify trustworthiness.
I ordered both these Nordicware pans and USA pans at the same time, and used them both for the first time, so there's no difference in age etc. I baked gingerbread cookies, and as you can see the ones baked on the Nordicwear pans cracked and I needed a spatula to scrape them off and some of the bottoms were left on the pan whereas the USA Pan cookies baked smooth and came off easily without a spatula needed. This is based off one time only and both new, so I can't speak to the wear of either or anything other than these cookies, so take this review as you will
I got these after hearing some great things people had to say about them. Unfortunately, while these don't warp in the traditional sense (sideways), they do warp down a bit. Meaning, now the pan isn't flat but has this bump in the middle of the surface that can be "popped" up or down, making the pan not flat. Shame
Water stains it. You need to dry it after you wash it. I tried drying it in the oven after washing at the water still stains it. It also warps around 400 degrees. Thought I’d be able to roast on it but it warps and makes everything puddle to one corner.
They came scratched already out of the box. They scratch really easily and the embossing of the logo in the pan is really annoying for cleaning. Could they not have put this on the bottom. They don't stack super well. They are pretty great pans though. The rolled rims get water in them and they're very thick.
At the same time, they're very thick and hearty. Quality pans. They're made in USA.
J'aime beaucoup la dimension de cette plaque. Très utile pour cuisiner divers repas au four. Elle ne semblais un peu chère mais je me disais que pour la qualité cela en valait la peine. Toutefoiss après un mois d'utilisation elle commence a avoir des tâches que je n'arrive pas a faire disparaitre, même si nous lavons toujours la plaque tout de suite après avoir cuisiné. Pour moi, ça ne vaut donc pas le prix.
One of the two trays was dented and stained, disappointed. No local stock to return and replace. Amazon provides no option for partial refund in such cases for accepting damaged defective items for the lack of quicker replacements.
The product is fine and being aluminum heats up very quickly. The problem I have is my pan was shipped with other items and it was seriously dented by third items. The dents protrude to the cooking side as bumps. Not sure I can recommend buying these if they are showing up damaged.