To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we do not use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyses reviews to verify trustworthiness.
This is one of the better lids on the market, for sure. I wouldn’t say it’s leak proof, but more like leak resistant, as if you leave it sitting on its side for a while, a little bit will come out. I also feel like the flow is restricted compared to other lids. But, if you’re looking for an upgrade from the standard Hydroflask straw lid, this is absolutely it.
I should add the removable mouth pieces are a really nice touch.
Just got these! I wanted the straw lid for a while but had a hard time finding the right one. I tried these out & it fits my ThermoFlask perfectly which I’m happy about. It doesn’t leak from the neck, as long as you have it closed tightly. It does leak a tiny bit from straw lid piece on top but I was holding it upside down testing if it is leakproof so I’d say it’s pretty good. The suction power is great and I think it’s good quality overall.
Although I loved my straw lid that originally came with my first iron flask, the two that I received recently kind of suck. They’re made out of cheaper plastic and one of the clips had a piece of the plastic carved out so it doesn’t clip shut like it’s supposed to. The lid does still keep water from leaking and the suction is great, but only if you don’t mind cheap plastic that may break away after some time!
I bought these for my kids, I do like them but if the bottle is on the floor it will occasionally leak so I would not say completely leak proof, I would not throw in my backpack without making sure it is upright. It is also hard for my kids to open on their own. Other then that works great!
These were the perfect fit for my water bottle, except I had to cut them down just a little bit to make them fit. I guess that is a good problem to have. If it was too short, that would be a real issue.
Sometimes I get some air when drinking, sometimes I don't. I like the soft tip on the straw and it's nice that I can remove it to clean it. Doesn't really leak, once or twice but I had to push it all the way on.
Fits my 40oz Thermoflask perfectly with no leaks. The only downside is the straw is not long enough therfore I can't drink my bottle empty. Straw should be longer so we can trim to fit, but maybe they have a longer version that i dont know about.